IJMLSP Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
Publication Ethics And Malpractice Statement
Contents
Duties of Editors
- Publication Decisions: Final decisions are guided by editorial policy, legal requirements, research integrity, and peer review.
- Fair Peer Review: Manuscripts are evaluated solely on intellectual and scholarly merit; appropriate anonymity and confidentiality are maintained.
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts and related materials must not be disclosed beyond appropriate parties.
- Identifying & Preventing Misconduct: Editors remain vigilant for misconduct and follow appropriate publication-ethics principles for investigation and corrective action.
- Conflict of Interest: Editors with conflicts must recuse themselves; responsibility should be reassigned to an appropriately independent editor.
- Research Integrity: Editors may request clarification, supporting documentation, methodological information, or other evidence necessary to assess the accuracy and integrity of a submission.
- Editorial Independence: Editorial decisions concerning corrections, Expressions of Concern, retractions, complaints, and appeals are based on documented evidence and research-integrity considerations. Authors, institutions, editors, or other parties must not pressure the journal to conceal legitimate concerns or manipulate the published record.
Duties of Reviewers
Reviewers must follow ethical principles and support the editorial process:
- Contribution to Editorial Decisions: Feedback supports editorial decisions and improves manuscript quality.
- Promptness: Notify the editor if unqualified, unavailable, or unable to complete the review within the required timeframe.
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts and unpublished research information are strictly confidential.
- Objectivity: Professional, evidence-based evaluation is required; personal criticism is prohibited.
- Acknowledgment of Sources: Alert the editor to uncited relevant work or substantial overlap with existing literature.
- Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must recuse themselves where a conflict of interest exists.
- Use of Artificial Intelligence: Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, unpublished manuscript content, peer-review reports, or other restricted material into generative AI systems where doing so would compromise confidentiality. Reviewers remain responsible for protecting the confidentiality and integrity of the peer-review process.
Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern
IJMLSP is committed to maintaining the integrity, accuracy, and reliability of the published scholarly record. Editorial action is determined according to the nature and significance of the identified problem, distinguishing between minor production errors, substantive errors, and research or publication misconduct.
A correction may be issued when an error does not invalidate the principal findings but materially affects the accuracy, interpretation, identification, or usability of the published record. Examples include incorrect author information, affiliations, tables, figures, bibliographic information, metadata, significant typographical errors, or other factual and production errors.
Minor errors that do not affect meaning, interpretation, identification, or scholarly usefulness may be corrected without a formal correction notice where appropriate. Such corrections should not alter the scholarly substance of the publication.
Retraction may be considered where compelling evidence indicates that a publication is seriously unreliable or violates fundamental principles of research or publication integrity.
An Expression of Concern may be published when a potentially serious problem has been identified, available evidence is insufficient for an immediate final decision, or an institutional investigation is ongoing.
Grounds for Retraction
- Fabrication or falsification of data.
- Major plagiarism or serious ethical violations.
- Duplicate or redundant publication.
- Fraudulent or seriously inappropriate authorship.
- Manipulated peer review.
- Major errors that invalidate principal conclusions.
- Unlawful or unauthorized use of protected research material.
- Other serious forms of publication misconduct.
Retraction Procedure
- Assess the available evidence.
- Contact the authors for an explanation where appropriate.
- Request supporting documentation or relevant evidence.
- Consult editors or independent experts where necessary.
- Contact the relevant institution or ethics body where appropriate.
- Determine whether correction, retraction, Expression of Concern, or another action is warranted.
Retraction Notices & Preservation of the Scholarly Record
A retraction notice should identify the affected article, clearly state that the article has been retracted, explain the principal reason, and remain permanently accessible. The original article should normally remain part of the scholarly record with a clear retraction status rather than being silently deleted.
Authorship Corrections
Requests concerning authorship after publication must be supported by evidence and agreement among affected authors where possible. The journal may request institutional involvement in disputed cases. Changes to published authorship will normally be documented through a formal correction.
Ethical Investigation & Cooperation
IJMLSP may cooperate with universities, research institutions, funding bodies, ethics committees, publishers, indexing services, and other appropriate organizations when necessary to investigate research-integrity concerns.
Transparency is maintained when corrective action is taken. Retraction does not normally erase the scholarly record; its purpose is to clearly identify unreliable research while preserving an accurate historical record of publication.
Data Availability & Research Transparency
IJMLSP supports transparent reporting of research while recognizing legitimate ethical, legal, privacy, confidentiality, copyright, licensing, and contractual restrictions on the sharing of research data.
General Principle
Authors should provide sufficient information about their research methods, materials, data, analytical procedures, and sources to enable readers to understand and evaluate the research. Where appropriate and ethically permissible, supporting research materials should be made available.
Research articles should include a data-availability statement where applicable, indicating whether supporting data are publicly available, available upon reasonable request, available under specified conditions, restricted, or not applicable.
Where relevant, authors are encouraged to make available questionnaires, interview protocols, coding schemes, corpora, analytical scripts, experimental materials, supplementary tables, and research instruments, subject to applicable restrictions.
Human-Participant Data
Personal or identifiable participant data must not be publicly released where doing so would violate informed consent, privacy, confidentiality, institutional requirements, applicable law, or ethical approval conditions. Authors must anonymize or otherwise appropriately protect sensitive information.
Research-Specific Transparency
- Qualitative Research: Authors should provide sufficient methodological information concerning interviews, observations, ethnographic research, classroom research, and similar approaches without compromising participant confidentiality.
- Corpus Research: Authors should report corpus composition, data sources, sampling procedures, inclusion and exclusion criteria, annotation procedures, analytical methods, and relevant corpus-access restrictions.
- Quantitative Research: Authors should report participants or observations, sampling, variables, measures, analytical procedures, statistical methods, relevant assumptions, and missing-data procedures where applicable.
- Reproducibility: Where feasible, authors are encouraged to provide supplementary materials, analytical code, instruments, or other materials necessary to support reproducibility.
Data Integrity & Third-Party Data
Authors must not fabricate, falsify, selectively manipulate, or deceptively report research data. Where an error in published data is discovered, authors should notify the Editorial Office promptly.
Authors using third-party datasets must comply with relevant access conditions, licenses, copyright requirements, confidentiality requirements, and ethical restrictions.
AI-Generated or Synthetic Data
Where AI-generated or synthetic data are used, authors must clearly disclose the nature of the generated data, the tool or system used, the purpose of its use, relevant generation procedures, and limitations affecting interpretation.
Synthetic data must not be presented as naturally observed human data or as empirical evidence when they do not represent actual observations.
Complaints & Appeals
IJMLSP aims to handle complaints and appeals fairly, transparently, confidentially, and without retaliation.
Editorial Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they believe that a significant factual misunderstanding affected the decision, a major procedural error occurred, relevant information was overlooked, or the peer-review process was demonstrably inconsistent with the journal's stated policy.
Disagreement with an editorial decision alone is not normally sufficient grounds for an appeal. Appeals must provide specific reasons and supporting evidence.
Appeal Procedure
An appeal should be submitted through the official Editorial Office contact channel and should include:
- Manuscript title.
- Manuscript identification number.
- Date of the editorial decision.
- Specific grounds for appeal.
- Relevant evidence.
- Any factual clarification believed to have been overlooked.
The editor may uphold the original decision, request clarification, obtain an independent editorial assessment, or invite an additional reviewer where appropriate.
An appeal does not guarantee reconsideration or acceptance. Where an independent assessment confirms that the original decision was reasonable, the decision may be considered final.
Complaints About Peer Review
Complaints concerning reviewer conduct, confidentiality, reviewer conflicts of interest, inappropriate comments, or suspected review manipulation will be assessed by the editorial leadership.
Complaints About Editorial Conduct
Concerns regarding an editor should, where possible, be directed to a senior editor who was not involved in the matter. Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the publisher or designated institutional authority may be involved.
Publication Ethics Complaints
Concerns involving plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, manipulated peer review, or other publication misconduct will be investigated under the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.
IJMLSP may cooperate with relevant institutions, ethics bodies, publishers, funding organizations, or other appropriate authorities when necessary.
Complaints and appeals will be handled confidentially to the extent reasonably possible. Information may be disclosed where necessary to investigate the matter or comply with legal, institutional, or ethical obligations.
The journal does not tolerate retaliation against individuals who raise legitimate concerns in good faith.
Threats, harassment, discriminatory communication, coercion, or attempts to influence editorial decisions through inappropriate means will not be tolerated and may result in suspension of communication or other appropriate action.